Sign In
  • Support FanGraphs
    FanGraphs Membership
    FanGraphs Shirts
    FanGraphs Mugs
    Gift a Membership
    Donate to FanGraphs
  • Games
    Ottoneu Fantasy Baseball
    Signup, FAQ, Blog Posts
  • Blogs
    Blog Roll

    FanGraphs
    Podcasts: FanGraphs Audio | Effectively Wild | Chin Music

    FanGraphs Prospects

    RotoGraphs
    Podcasts: The Sleeper and The Bust | Field of Streams | Beat the Shift

    Community Research

    Archived Blogs: The Hardball Times | NotGraphs | TechGraphs | FanGraphs+
    Archived THT: THT Live | Dispatch | Fantasy | ShysterBall
    Archived Podcasts: Stealing Home | Doing It For Bartolo | OttoGraphs | UMP: The Untitled McDongenhagen Project
  • Projections
    2023 Pre-Season Projections
    ZiPS, ZiPS DC
    Steamer
    Depth Charts
    ATC
    THE BAT, THE BAT X
    2023 600 PA / 200 IP Projections
    Steamer600
    2023 Updated In-Season Projections
    ZiPS (RoS), ZiPS (Update)
    Steamer (RoS), Steamer (Update)
    Depth Charts (RoS)
    THE BAT (RoS), THE BAT X (RoS)
    3 Year Projections
    ZiPS 2024, ZiPS 2025
    On-Pace Leaders
    Every Game Played, Games Played %
    Auction Calculator
  • Scores
    Today
    Live Scoreboard, Probable Pitchers
    Live Daily Leaderboards
    Win Probability & Box Scores
    2022, 2021, 2020, 2019, 2018, 2017...
  • Standings
    2022 Projected Standings
    2022 Playoff Odds, Playoff Odds Graphs
    ZiPS Postseason Game-By-Game Odds
    AL East
    AL Central
    AL West
    NL East
    NL Central
    NL West
  • Leaders
    Major League Leaders
    Batting: 2022, 2021, 2020, 2019, 2018, Career
    Pitching: 2022, 2021, 2020, 2019, 2018, Career
    Fielding: 2022, 2021, 2020, 2019, 2018, Career
    Splits Leaderboards
    Season Stat Grid
    60-Game Span Leaderboards (Special)

    KBO Leaders
    Batting, Pitching

    Minor League Leaders
    AAA: Triple-A East, Triple-A West, Mexican
    AA: Double-A Northeast, Double-A South, Double-A Central
    A+: High-A Central, High-A East, High-A West
    A: Low-A West, Low-A East, Low-A Southeast
    R: Appalachian, Gulf Coast, Pioneer, Arizona
    R: Dominican
    WAR Tools
    Combined WAR Leaderboards
    WAR Graphs
    WPA Tools
    WPA Inquirer
    Rookie Leaders
    Batters 2022, Pitchers 2022
    Splits Leaders
    Batters: vs L, vs R, Home, Away
    Pitchers: vs L , vs R, Home, Away
  • Teams
    Team Batting Stats
    2022, 2021, 2020, 2019, 2018, 2017...
    Team Pitching Stats
    2022, 2021, 2020, 2019, 2018, 2017...
    Team WAR Totals (RoS)
    AL East
    Blue Jays  |  DC
    Orioles  |  DC
    Rays  |  DC
    Red Sox  |  DC
    Yankees  |  DC
    AL Central
    Guardians  |  DC
    Royals  |  DC
    Tigers  |  DC
    Twins  |  DC
    White Sox  |  DC
    AL West
    Angels  |  DC
    Astros  |  DC
    Athletics  |  DC
    Mariners  |  DC
    Rangers  |  DC
    NL East
    Braves  |  DC
    Marlins  |  DC
    Mets  |  DC
    Nationals  |  DC
    Phillies  |  DC
    NL Central
    Brewers  |  DC
    Cardinals  |  DC
    Cubs  |  DC
    Pirates  |  DC
    Reds  |  DC
    NL West
    D-backs  |  DC
    Dodgers  |  DC
    Giants  |  DC
    Padres  |  DC
    Rockies  |  DC
    Positional Depth Charts
    Batters: C, 1B, 2B, SS, 3B, LF, CF, RF, DH
    Pitchers: SP, RP
  • RosterResource
    Current Depth Charts
    AL East
    Blue Jays
    Orioles
    Rays
    Red Sox
    Yankees
    AL Central
    Guardians
    Royals
    Tigers
    Twins
    White Sox
    AL West
    Angels
    Astros
    Athletics
    Mariners
    Rangers
    NL East
    Braves
    Marlins
    Mets
    Nationals
    Phillies
    NL Central
    Brewers
    Cardinals
    Cubs
    Pirates
    Reds
    NL West
    D-backs
    Dodgers
    Giants
    Padres
    Rockies
    Offseason Tools
    2023 Opening Day Tracker
    2023 Offseason Tracker
    2023 Free Agent Tracker
    In-Season Tools
    2023 Closer Depth Chart
    2023 Injury Report
    2022 Lineup Tracker
    2023 Payroll Pages
    2022 Probables Grid
    2022 Schedule Grid
    2023 Transaction Tracker
  • Prospects
    Prospects Home
    THE BOARD!
    THE BOARD: Scouting + Stats!
    How To Use THE BOARD: A Tutorial
    Top Prospects List
    Top Prospects
    2023 2022
    AL
    BALCHWHOU
    BOSCLELAA
    NYYDETOAK
    TBRKCRSEA
    TORMINTEX
    NL
    ATLCHCARI
    MIACINCOL
    NYMMILLAD
    PHIPITSDP
    WSNSTLSFG
    AL
    BALCHWHOU
    BOSCLELAA
    NYYDETOAK
    TBRKCRSEA
    TORMINTEX
    NL
    ATLCHCARI
    MIACINCOL
    NYMMILLAD
    PHIPITSDP
    WSNSTLSFG

    • 2022 Preseason Top 100

  • Glossary
    Library
    Batting Stats
    wOBA, wRC+, ISO, K% & BB%, more...
    Pitching Stats
    FIP, xFIP, BABIP, K/9 & BB/9, more...
    Defensive Stats
    UZR Primer, DRS, FSR, TZ & TZL, more...
    More
    WAR, UBR Primer, WPA, LI, Clutch
    Guts!
    Seasonal Constants
    Park Factors
    Park Factors by Handedness
  • Sign In
Help Support FanGraphs


Become a Member No Thanks
Already a member? Log In
  • Intro
  • Features
  • Offense
    • Complete List (Offense)
    • OBP
    • OPS and OPS+
    • wOBA
    • wRC and wRC+
    • wRAA
    • Off
    • BsR
    • UBR
    • wSB
    • wGDP
    • BABIP
    • ISO
    • HR/FB
    • Spd
    • Pull%/Cent%/Oppo%
    • Soft%/Med%/Hard%
    • GB%, LD%, FB%
    • K% and BB%
    • Plate Discipline (O-Swing%, Z-Swing%, etc.)
    • Pitch Type Linear Weights
    • Pace
  • Defense
    • Overview
    • Def
    • UZR
    • DRS
    • Defensive Runs Saved – 2020 Update
    • Inside Edge Fielding
    • Catcher Defense
    • FSR
    • RZR
    • TZ / TZL
  • Pitching
    • Complete List (Pitching)
    • ERA
    • WHIP
    • FIP
    • xFIP
    • SIERA
    • Strikeout and Walk Rates
    • Pull%/Cent%/Oppo%
    • Soft%/Med%/Hard%
    • GB%, LD%, FB%
    • BABIP
    • HR/FB
    • LOB%
    • Pitch Type Linear Weights
    • SD / MD
    • ERA- / FIP- / xFIP-
    • Plate Discipline (O-Swing%, Z-Swing%, etc.)
    • Pace
    • PITCHF/x
      • What is PITCHF/x?
      • Pitch Type Abbreviations & Classifications
      • Heat Maps
      • Common Mistakes
      • PITCHf/x Resources
  • WE/RE/LI
    • RE24
    • Win Expectancy
    • WPA
    • LI
    • WPA/LI
    • Clutch
  • Principles
    • DIPS
    • Regression toward the Mean
    • Replacement Level
    • Sample Size
    • Splits
    • Projection Systems
    • Linear Weights
    • Counting vs. Rate Statistics
    • Park Factors
    • Park Factors – 5 Year Regressed
    • Positional Adjustment
    • Aging Curve
    • League Equivalencies
    • Pythagorean Win-Loss
    • Luck
  • WAR
    • What is WAR?
    • WAR for Position Players
    • WAR for Pitchers
    • FDP
    • fWAR, rWAR, and WARP
    • WAR Misconceptions
  • Business

Context: Neutral or Dependent?

by Neil Weinberg
August 17, 2015

Every statistic is an answer to a question. “How often does a batter reach base?” is answered by On-Base Percentage. “How many extra bases does a hitter average per at bat?” leads us to Isolated Power. A statistic is only as good as it’s generating question and if you’re asking a silly question, the statistic may give you a silly answer. Stats like pitcher wins, saves, and RBI all answer questions, but they don’t really answer questions we really want to know the answer to.

RBI, for example, tells you how many times a batter has had their hit, walk, or sacrifice fly lead directly to a runner crossing the plate. On the surface, this may seem like a useful statistic as a measure of run production. But you soon realize that RBI is reliant on the number of opportunities each player has to drive in runs. Coming to the plate with a man on first and coming to the plate with a man on third are not the same type of RBI opportunity, even if the batter hits a single in both situations.

In other words, RBI is a very crude context-dependent statistic. Generally, RBI isn’t very useful because it doesn’t provide you with a lot of information about individual player’s role in the production of a run. If they have a lot of RBI, did they have a ton of opportunities? Did they cash in on a large percentage of their opportunities? You don’t really know. But the fact that RBI doesn’t provide much insight does not mean that context-dependent stats aren’t valuable when designed properly. Essentially, context-neutral and context-dependent stats are both useful, but they are simply answering different questions.

A context-neutral stat is one that values a given action equally no matter the circumstances in which the event occurred. For example, stats like wOBA, wRC+, wRAA, and many others give equal credit for singles in the first inning of a blowout and the 10th inning of a tie game. A double has the same value if the bases are loaded with two outs or if the bases are empty with no outs. The action is the action, no matter what.

A context-dependent stat varies the values a given action has depending on circumstances over which the player has no control. Stats like RE24 or WPA give different values to the same action dependent on the state of the game around the player. A double with the bases loaded is treated differently than a double with no one on base.

In sabermetric circles, there is a lot of emphasis on context-neutral numbers because research has generally found that “clutch” performance isn’t a skill, and that good hitters will generally hit well and bad hitters generally won’t. Performance in certain contexts rarely predicts performance in future, similar contexts above and beyond a player’s skill level. As a result, when we look at individual players, we often look at their context-neutral numbers. That doesn’t mean context-dependent numbers are useless, they just generally don’t answer the questions that many saber-minded people are asking.

But context-dependent stats certainly have merit in describing past value if you are specifically interested in how a player performed relative to his situations. Many people prefer context-dependent numbers for awards like MVP because they care about how much a player’s hits increased their team’s chance of scoring or winning. It might help to think of these as “impact stats.” A double is a double according to Batting Runs (basically wOBA scaled to PA), but how much did that double impact the inning in question? We need RE24 (change in run expectancy) for that.

According to Batting Runs (the batting component of WAR), a double is worth somewhere around 0.73 runs above average. In other words, on average, doubles add 0.73 runs for a team. But every single double doesn’t add exactly 0.73 runs because partial runs aren’t a thing. A bases-empty, two-out double is only worth about 0.2 runs on average and a bases-loaded, two-out double is worth about 2.6 runs on average. Do you want to give credit to the batter based on the average value of the action or the value of the action as it happened? It’s a decision you have to make as the person asking the question.

You can take it a step further and add in the inning and score, which will help you get to Win Probability Added (WPA) instead of simply run expectancy. Now that bases-loaded, two-out double is worth even more if your team was down two runs, but much less if your team was up by six. It all comes down to how much context you want to include in your evaluation.

Most people would argue that RBI includes too much of the wrong kind of context. RBI only gives you credit if you’re the batter who drives the run in and doesn’t give you credit if you are 1) the runner who got on base to be driven in, or 2) if you move a runner up and they are later driven in by another batter. RE24, on the other hand, gives you proper credit no matter what your role was in scoring that run.

For example, if an inning starts with three singles and then three strikeouts, the first batter likely gets a run scored, the second batter gets nothing, and the third batter gets an RBI. With RE24, the first batter gets 0.37 runs, the second batter gets 0.54 runs, and the third batter gets 1.00 runs (assuming no one goes first to third, and runner from second scores). This still gives more credit to the guy who gets the third hit, but it also gives proper value to the man in the middle, who was critical to the run scoring.

It all comes down to deciding what kind of evaluation you want to make when using value based statistics. If you’re looking at OBP, you either reached base or you didn’t, but when you’re looking at wOBA, those weights are based on average run values. Sometimes you might want to use those average values and sometimes you might want to know the run expectancy of the individual situations. If you care about the player’s individual performance, context-neutral probably makes sense. If you care about their impact on individual moments, context-dependent is probably the way to go.

The key is always to use the right stat for the question. If you want to know how well a player hit, you probably want to only judge the pitcher-batter confrontation, but if you want to specifically know how much a batter aided his team’s odds of winning today, WPA might make more sense.  Never pick out a stat and use it to determine your question. That’s how people have wound up thinking RBI is a good measure of context-dependent value even though it isn’t. Determine the question you want to answer and then find a stat that is designed to do so. Sometimes that leads you to a context-neutral number and sometimes it leads you to a context-dependent one.





The Beginner’s Guide To Single-Season BABIP
 
The Beginner’s Guide To Pulling A Starting Pitcher

Neil Weinberg is the Site Educator at FanGraphs and can be found writing enthusiastically about the Detroit Tigers at New English D. Follow and interact with him on Twitter @NeilWeinberg44.

1 Comment
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
David
7 years ago

I think Fangraphs is the most worthless site on the net. It has taken the beautiful game of baseball, which is a nineteenth-century pastoral game, and tried to turn it into the disgusting spectacle of every other sport.

Baseball is and always will be apart and separate, and much more in tune with the hard-wiring of the human condition – because it is the game which beats down the individual in order to advance the community. It is the sport which ponders INaction, which calculates the effect of the community’s effort, not the individual, except for pitchers.

Pitching is 98% of the game, and the only real beauty of the game. If you have that, you don’t really need anything else. baseball is the only game where the defense has the ball. With the exception of maybe Ted Williams and Willie Mays, there’s really no such thing as good hitting in baseball – it is just the momentary failure of perfect pitching.

All these statistics and memes and projections are fine, if that’s what you’re into – but it is not now, nor will it ever be the soul of the game.

-12
You are going to send email to

Move Comment

Updated: Saturday, January 28, 2023 7:05 AM ETUpdated: 1/28/2023 7:05 AM ET
Player Linker - @fangraphs - Contact Us - Advertise - Terms of Service - Privacy Policy
sis_logo
All major league baseball data including pitch type, velocity, batted ball location, and play-by-play data provided by Sports Info Solutions.
mlb logo
Major League and Minor League Baseball data provided by Major League Baseball.
Mitchel Lichtman
All UZR (ultimate zone rating) calculations are provided courtesy of Mitchel Lichtman.
TangoTiger.com
All Win Expectancy, Leverage Index, Run Expectancy, and Fans Scouting Report data licenced from TangoTiger.com
Retrosheet.org
Play-by-play data prior to 2002 was obtained free of charge from and is copyrighted by Retrosheet.